Securing AI: A CISO's Guide to Threat Modeling

Key Takeaways (Implementation Starting Today) 

1. Start documenting AI system components immediately - even a simple spreadsheet listing models, data sources, and access points provides visibility 

2. Schedule a threat modeling workshop within the next 2 weeks with key stakeholders (development, security, legal teams) 

3. Begin implementing basic access controls around AI systems while building out comprehensive security measures 

The story of InnovateAI (names changed for anonymity), $250M revenue SaaS company, provides valuable insights into securing enterprise AI systems. 

When InnovateAI's CISO Sarah Chen (name changed for anonymity) first heard about the CEO's proposal to implement generative AI for reducing customer service costs (projected $2M annual savings), she approached the project with careful consideration. 

“The company's customer data represented our most valuable asset, and securing an AI system with access to this information required thorough planning.”

Let's examine how InnovateAI approached this challenge. 

Step 1: System Decomposition - Making the Invisible Visible 

Imagine trying to protect a house without knowing where the doors and windows are. That's what securing an AI system feels like without proper decomposition. 

InnovateAI started by creating what Sarah calls their "AI Inventory." 

The security team mapped: 

• Input/output flows (Where does customer data enter and exit?) 

• Model details (Which version of GPT are they using? What fine-tuning have they done?) 

• Infrastructure components (Where is everything hosted? Who has access?) 

• Data linkages (How does customer data move through their systems?) 

Pro tip: The team used a simple diagram tool like draw.io to create this map. 

“After spending two days on this exercise, we discovered three unknown API endpoints that hadn't been considered in our initial security planning.” Sarah, CISO

Step 2: Threat Identification - Thinking Like an Attacker 

After one of InnovateAI's competitors had their AI system tricked into revealing customer email addresses, the security team knew they needed robust threat identification. 

They assembled their "red team" - a mix of security engineers, AI developers, and customer service leads who understood how the system might be misused. 

The team used MITRE ATLAS as their framework.

Key threats identified: 

1. Prompt injection attacks (Think SQL injection, but for AI) 

2. Training data extraction (Competitors trying to rebuild their models) 

3. Authorization bypass (Unauthorized access to customer conversations) 

Step 3: Risk Analysis - Making the Case for Security 

This is where Sarah, the CISO won over the board. The team translated technical risks into business impact: 

"If our AI system is compromised, we risk exposing 50,000 customer conversations, resulting in potential regulatory fines of $500 per record under GDPR." 

CISO talking point for stakeholders: "Our AI system processes 10,000 customer interactions daily. A security incident could result in immediate financial loss and long-term reputation damage." 

Step 4: Mitigation - Building Your Defense 

InnovateAI implemented a defense-in-depth approach: 

1. Input validation before requests reach the AI 

2. Output scanning for sensitive data patterns 

3. Rate limiting to prevent abuse 

4. Access controls with role-based permissions 

5. Continuous monitoring for unusual patterns 

Question 1: "How do you justify the cost of AI security measures to the board?" 

Answer: "I framed it around risk vs. reward. Our AI system saves $2M annually in customer service costs, but a single data breach could cost $25M in fines and lost business. The $400K spent upfront on security measures serves as insurance for our AI investment." 

Question 2: "What's the first step I should take tomorrow morning?" 

Answer: "Start with an inventory. You can't protect what you don't know about. Get a coffee, open Excel, and list every AI system, model, and data source in your organization. It's not glamorous, but it's the foundation of everything else. Get this first step right." 

Conclusion: What next? 

Securing AI is a critical priority for CISOs, yet the full scope and potential financial impact is often underestimated by Senior Leaders and Board Members. Being explicit with data-driven statistics in a way that resonates with the audience, will support CISOs in getting wider support to take appropriate action or investment. 

Complacency in AI security is not an option. New attack vectors, threat actors, and techniques are evolving year after year. 

By following the four steps outlined above, you can ensure that your AI security strategy stays proactive and resilient.

Read the sequel to learn more about the AI-specific terms you’ll need to know for your journey; The CISO's Guide to AI Terms: Speaking the Language of Machine Learning.

#AISecurity #CISO #ThreatModeling

‍